Mr. Marlboro Strikes Again

Friday, 17 August 2018 05:40 PM

 

The Scene

In 2014, Canada’s Parliament was attacked by Michael Zehaf-Bibeau, a lone wolf, in an act that was celebrated by numerous terrorist organizations around the world. This was followed by several terrorist attacks in Europe such as the Charlie Hebdo massacre, also inspired and ultimately claimed for credit by Islamic extremists.  Then there came the Paris attacks of November 2015 and the San Bernardino shooting that followed.  Significantly, the Bamako, Mali attacks of November 20, 2015 that resulted in 170 hostages and 20 deaths was sponsored by none other than Mr. Marlboro, Mokhtar Belmokhtar, leader of Al Qaeda in the Islamic Maghreb (AQIM).

 

Mr. Marlboro picked up the terrorist pace in 2016 with the Burkina Faso attack on January 15 where at least 28 people from seven countries were killed and 50 other people were wounded. No longer is Canada immune from global terrorism and the effects of the radical jihadist forces such as those being organized, financed, and directed by the likes of Mr. Marlboro.  The attacks in the Splendid Hotel in Burkina Faso took the lives of six Quebec missionaries who were having a final meal in the hotel before heading back to Canada after completing their humanitarian mission in Africa.

 

The history and ongoing attacks by groups such as ISIL within Western democracies shows the need for vigilance by our security forces.  Many strategies for military-like responses to jihadist events have been tried and still the attacks continue.  Increasingly, the enemy is infiltrating our borders and threatening our lives. 

 

Especially in the case of Belmoktar, Canadians need to realize that whenever contraband cigarettes are sold or bought in Canada, that activity may well find its way to supporting the terrorist cause.  Moreover, for any Canadian or First Nations participants in the manufacturing or production of illicit tobacco products that find their way into the global black market, these individuals and groups are directly responsible for funding Mr. Marlboro’s world of horror.

 

AQIM, ISIL and other radical jihadist groups depend on money to succeed.  Sophisticated plans, the latest weaponry, and leading-edge communications and intelligence technologies are expensive and require a high volume, risk averse financing system to fund attacks. By removing access to money sources, terrorists’ operational base evaporates.

 

Fighting Threats:  Role of the Fiscal System

The increasing sophistication of extremists to fundraise for operations within the West and support a flow of money to their main hubs has posed a major challenge for security forces.

 

In Canada, efforts to control the monetary supply to criminal causes has been primarily spearheaded by FINTRAC (Financial Transactions and Reports Analysis Centre of Canada) and Canada Revenue Agency’s investigative branches along with support of financial institutions. With improved ability to track accounts and algorithms for identification of suspects, it has allowed for the seizure of funds and identification of end accounts controlled by terrorist organizations. This has resulted in illicit money laundering becoming more risky and harder for terrorists to use the legitimate financial system as the vehicle for transport of money.

 

Illicit Cigarettes – Fuelling Jihadist Objectives

As the clampdown on financial systems by organizations like Canada’ FINTRAC come online, the jihadists look to alternative, less risky models to fund their expensive operations.  One of the most prevalent systems for money laundering is to look for commonly desired goods as the vehicle for transfer. This often takes the form of a Hawala network where goods are bought by the launderer then sold and shipped to the recipient at far below market cost for re-sale at the higher market rate thereby creating larger profits and associated wealth transfer.

 

Since the early successes of terrorists such as Belmoktar’s kidnapping of Canadian diplomat, Robert Fowler in 2009, illegal tobacco has become the target commodity used to raise large sums of money.  Two things specifically make illegal cigarettes attractive to terrorists.    First, in any country, approximately twenty percent of the population are smokers so the product itself is seen as relatively benign.  Second, governments like to think that cigarettes can be taxed at very high levels so the disparity between production costs and retail price becomes a target pricing formula for smugglers.

 

Canada’s unintended collusion with international terrorist funding enterprises is very troubling indeed.  First, provincial and federal authorities seem to turn a blind eye towards the impact of their taxing regimes so ordinary people look for cheaper alternatives than the high prices they will pay for legitimate, fully taxed product in convenience stores and gas bars.  Second, the precarious state of relations with First Nations in Canada prevents any serious effort to fix the root of the problem – the large scale production and international distribution of untaxed cigarettes without the interference by government or law enforcement authorities. 

 

Illicit tobacco is a proven vehicle both for money laundering and funding terrorist activities.  Either small, lone wolf type attacks or more coordinated efforts on the part of jihadist forces will continue to benefit from the proceeds from the tobacco trade unless serious effort is put into stopping it.

 

Gaps in Canada’s Response

Ineffective law enforcement and legislative inaction have resulted in the legitimate tobacco industry developing and implementing a business exit strategy for the Canadian tobacco growers which, ultimately, will result in the demise of the entire Southwestern Ontario economy.  More problematic is the fact that if farmers don’t sell raw tobacco to legitimate producers, their crops will find their way to the more than 50 illegal cigarette factories located in native reserves in Ontario and Quebec.

 

Canada needs to get a grip on the issue before it becomes known as a global financial support structure for radical jihadist activity.  Already there are many Latin American countries complaining that the illegal cigarette manufacturers in Canada are ruining local economies with smuggling networks that extend from Akwesasne, Six Nations and other Canadian reserves to cartels in the area.  If it becomes clear – and eventually it will – that the same illicit Canadian tobacco production is fuelling the operations of ISIS, AQIM, Hezbollah, Hamas and other extremists, it will hopefully not be too late for Canadian authorities to act.  The consequences of not acting quickly and responsibly may end up in more death and injury to Canadians at home and abroad.

 

Edward R. Myers is a freelance journalist and can be reached as follows:

 

Telephone:  613-986-5756

 

e-mail:  [email protected]